LLMs are great tutoring tools

The original illustration for LLMs are great tutoring tools: Einstein's face above an orange desert, with a small explorer in the foreground

LLMs are great at simplifying complexity and personalizing knowledge

Large Language Models (LLMs) are incredibly powerful tools, yet we're not fully leveraging their potential for education because today's interfaces remain abstract and unfocused.

I asked GPT to explain four-dimensional spacetime one step at a time. I wanted to see how far it could take a student, starting with the familiar example of a moving train. Here’s the answer it gave me.

Einstein didn't suddenly grasp 4-dimensional spacetime. He built up his understanding step by step, using simple ideas and experiments. Here's a straightforward breakdown of the incremental steps he took:

Step 1: Observing simple facts about motion

Einstein started with a simple observation:

  • If you're in a smoothly moving train (no acceleration), you can't tell if you're moving or standing still without looking outside. This is called the Principle of Relativity: Uniform motion can't be detected without external references.

Step 2: Understanding the speed of light

Next, Einstein learned about an important discovery made before him (by Maxwell and measured by Michelson-Morley experiments):

  • The speed of light is always constant (about 300,000 km/s), no matter how fast you or the source of light moves. This seemed strange: Usually, speeds depend on the observer's motion (e.g., if you chase a car, it seems slower), but light didn't behave like this.

Step 3: Challenging the idea of absolute time

Since light speed is constant for everyone, Einstein realized that something else had to change: time and space. He concluded that:

  • Time isn't absolute; it runs differently for people moving relative to each other.
  • Distances can also change when you move very fast. This led to Special Relativity (1905): Moving clocks run slower and moving objects shorten their length.

Step 4: Combining space and time

Because space and time are both affected by motion, Einstein began to see them as one combined "fabric" called spacetime:

  • Instead of treating space and time separately, he used a unified 4-dimensional description (3 dimensions of space + 1 dimension of time). Spacetime became his new fundamental concept: An event (like turning on a flashlight) happens at a specific point in space and at a specific moment in time. These coordinates form a single "location" in 4D spacetime.

Step 5: Understanding gravity as geometry

Next, Einstein wanted to explain gravity within this new idea of spacetime. He realized gravity isn't a force pulling things down, but something deeper:

  • Mass (like planets or stars) bends and curves spacetime around it.
  • Objects moving in this curved spacetime follow paths that we interpret as gravitational attraction. This is General Relativity (1915): Gravity is just curved spacetime. A heavy object like the Sun bends spacetime, and the Earth moves naturally along this curve, appearing as an orbit.

Step 6: Visualization (4D as curved fabric)

Einstein simplified visualization by comparing spacetime to a flexible rubber sheet:

  • Place a heavy ball (the Sun) on the sheet, and it curves inward.
  • Roll smaller balls (planets) across it, and they naturally spiral around the heavier mass. In reality, spacetime curvature happens in 4 dimensions: While we can't easily visualize this fully, the analogy helps us understand how gravity emerges from geometry.

Incremental summary of Einstein's path:

  • Basic Observations: Relative motion isn't detectable internally.
  • Constant Speed of Light: No matter your speed, light speed stays fixed.
  • Special Relativity (time/space flexible): Time slows, lengths shrink when you move fast.
  • Unifying Space-Time (4D): Time and space form a unified 4-dimensional "fabric." spacetime
  • General Relativity (Gravity as Geometry): Mass curves spacetime; gravity is just objects following this curvature.

Simply put:

Einstein didn't start with 4D directly; he built from basic experiments and logic, step-by-step, until he realized gravity, space, and time are deeply connected, forming our modern understanding of spacetime.

I like the order of the lesson. I’d pause at step two, though. Michelson and Morley looked for a change in the interference pattern when they turned their apparatus. The shift they expected from the Earth’s motion through the proposed ether never appeared. I’d ask a student what the experiment could actually establish before moving on to the next step. Michelson and Morley’s 1887 paper.

I’d use the rubber sheet in step six as a classroom aid. I’d want a source before telling a student that Einstein used it himself.

Originally published on LinkedIn, 14 March 2025.